Key Points
- First Selectman Toni Boucher cited the town’s standard practice when she turned down Finance Chair Tim Birch’s request for one or two members to listen to the Nov. 20 Moody’s call.
- BOF Vice Chair Rudy Escalante said he wanted to know what Moody’s expected of Wilton and who would follow through after CFO Dawn Savo leaves.
- Former First Selectwoman Lynne Vanderslice said she attended a Moody’s call as finance vice chair and later invited finance chairs to attend when she led the town.
Why It Matters: Wilton’s finance board learned about Moody’s summer ratings review after the fact. With the CFO leaving, transparency in the town’s financial reporting matters for oversight. Board members need to know what Moody’s asks of Wilton, what the town promises and who will follow through.
First Selectman Toni Boucher turned down a request from Board of Finance Chair Tim Birch to let one or two members listen to Wilton’s Friday, Nov. 20, credit rating call with Moody’s, renewing debate over Wilton’s financial management, governance and transparency around what town officials share with the boards responsible for Wilton’s finances and the public.
This past September, Wilton’s Board of Finance learned only after the fact that Moody’s had placed the town’s Aaa credit ratings under review June 30. The agency confirmed the ratings in September, but how town officials shared information about the review has remained a concern for finance board members.
Boucher’s decision comes as Chief Financial Officer Dawn Savo prepares to leave in two weeks, the second Wilton CFO to depart in as many years. The finance board has formed an Audit Remediation and Financial Reporting Subcommittee to address problems surrounding the town’s audit and financial reporting. Three selectmen also recently wrote in a GMW op-ed that they were “concerned about the leadership of our town,” citing senior staff departures and the handling of the audit.
BOF Vice Chair Rudy Escalante told GOOD Morning Wilton Friday morning that he wanted to know what Moody’s had asked, how the town had answered and who would follow through after Savo leaves.
“Have I seen the questions? Have I seen our answers? No,” he said.
Escalante said he was concerned the town might agree to several deadlines on the call. “So if we make commitments in that meeting, who’s going to do them?” he asked.
Now, in a Thursday, Nov. 19 email reviewed by GMW, Boucher told Birch and Escalante that she, Savo and the town’s bond advisor agreed to follow what she called “our standard practice which does not include any board members to achieve the best results.”
Responding to GMW Friday, Boucher pointed to Moody’s description of its rating process and said Wilton has followed the same procedure since she became first selectman.
Two selectmen told Boucher that letting a finance board member listen could help build trust between the boards.
And former First Selectwoman Lynne Vanderslice described firsthand how Wilton handled the calls during her years in town government. She told GMW she had attended a Moody’s call as BOF vice chair during Bill Brennan’s time as first selectman, and later continued to invite finance chairs when she succeeded him. Two attended during her tenure, she said.
Birch Asks for a Listening Role
Birch made his request Monday, Nov. 16, in an email to Boucher that was also sent to Savo and the boards of selectmen and finance. “We request that one or two members have listening privileges at the Moody’s Meeting Friday,” he wrote.
Second Selectman Ross Tartell replied Tuesday morning that Wilton planned to continue its established practice. He said the town’s bond counsel typically conducts the meetings with the first selectman, CFO and town administrator participating. Tartell said former Wilton First Selectmen Paul Hannah and Brennan, along with the first selectmen of Darien, New Canaan, Weston and Ridgefield, had described practices consistent with Wilton’s approach.
“As BOF Chair, you may request to attend the Moody’s meeting,” Tartell wrote to Birch. He also invited Birch or another BOF member to the December bond sale.
Escalante wrote to both boards Wednesday evening explaining why he supported Birch’s request. He cited CFO turnover, late audits and the failure to inform the finance board about the earlier ratings review. Moody’s had placed Wilton’s ratings under review June 30 because it lacked current financial information. It confirmed the ratings Sept. 25 after receiving draft FY2025 financial statements. Savo later apologized to the finance board for failing to inform members about the review.
Escalante also wrote that Moody’s was discussing a potential downgrade. Savo disputed that assertion Thursday morning. “Hi Rudy, Moody’s is not discussing a downgrade nor does our bond advisor believe that’s a possibility,” she wrote.
Asked Friday what led him to believe the rating could be at risk, Escalante pointed to the summer review and the FY2026 audit. He said he did not know what Moody’s expected Wilton to do next. “What are they expecting? I don’t know,” he said. A moment later, he added, “And can we do what they’re expecting?”
By Thursday morning, Birch said he was still waiting for an answer to Monday’s request. Boucher replied that she, Savo and the town’s bond adviser had reviewed and practiced the items for the call. She invited Birch and Escalante to the Dec. 9 bond sale.
Escalante asked for the agenda and questioned why finance chairs who had listened in the past could no longer do so. He also asked whether the meeting was secret.
“No, it is a private phone call, typically with Bond advisor and CFO,” Boucher replied.
In his Friday interview, Escalante took issue with Boucher’s description. “The bigger issue is that we are having discussions that are, to use Toni’s word, private, to use my word, secret, and we’re a town government. We shouldn’t be having secret meetings.”
What Boucher and the Bond Adviser Said About Attendance
In her Friday response to GMW, Boucher wrote, “Since assuming the role as First Selectman, this is the procedure we have followed as part of the normal bonding process.”
Boucher cited Moody’s confidentiality protections for nonpublic information supplied by an issuer, pending ratings and the rating committee’s deliberations. The Moody’s overview she linked describes a meeting at which the issuer’s management presents information to analysts. The rating committee deliberates at a later stage, and the issuer learns its rating before publication. The overview does not address whether a municipal finance board member may listen to the management meeting.
For a Board of Finance meeting on June 9, Wilton’s bond adviser Barry Bernabe provided written answers to members’ questions.
Bernabe confirmed that Moody’s prepares a list of topics they would like to discuss with the town during the rating call and confirmed that it was possible for the BOF to see what that outline or schedule looked like ahead of the review.
When asked who typically attends a Moody’s due diligence review, Bernabe identified the first selectman and CFO. He was asked about elected board members attending in other towns. “It is rare but I have seen it a few times in my 30 years as a municipal advisor, when someone from the Board of Finance sits in and observes the rating review.”
Raimondi and Tatkow Support Letting a BOF Member Listen
Boucher forwarded her decision to the Board of Selectmen. After Selectman Matt Raimondi urged her to let one or two members listen, she wrote, “I have spoken to our Bond Advisor and he feels strongly to limit those mentioned and not include board members for this call.”
Raimondi asked whether Boucher could share an email from Bernabe. Tartell pointed him to the June 9 answers.
“I do think there is an important distinction between the bond advisor noting that BOF participation is uncommon and explicitly recommending against it,” Raimondi replied.
A former BOF chair himself, Raimondi said he had once asked to participate in a Moody’s call and accepted town counsel’s advice that the decision rested with the first selectman. Birch had asked for a more limited role, Raimondi wrote. Members could listen without speaking or influencing the presentation.
Selectman David Tatkow also told Boucher he favored letting a BOF member listen if possible and would respect her decision. In a separate response to GMW Friday, Tatkow said the selectmen had never formally discussed Birch’s request. Given the boards’ experience with the summer review, he said, allowing access could have helped build trust. He said he would like the boards to discuss the merits and the reasons for limiting attendance before he took a stronger position.
Vanderslice Recalls Who Attended in Wilton
BOF member Kim Healy told both boards Thursday that she had asked Vanderslice and former finance chair Jeff Rutishauser about their experience. Healy said both recalled attending Moody’s calls while serving on the BOF. She also asked for copies of the agency’s advance questions and the town’s responses.
In written comments to GMW, Vanderslice said it was “standard operating procedure for the BOF chair to attend the Moody’s call” during her approximately six years as finance vice chair. She recalled attending once in place of then-Chair Warren Serenbetz, with Brennan, then the first selectman, also on the call.
Vanderslice said Serenbetz attended as BOF chair during her first year as first selectwoman. Rutishauser subsequently also attended during his five years as chair before telling Vanderslice that she and then-CFO Anne Kelly-Lenz needed little assistance from him on the calls. According to Vanderslice, he asked her to let him know if that changed. His successor, Mike Kaelin, also declined to attend for similar reasons, she said.
Escalante told GMW he knew Friday’s call had been scheduled but had received no details about it. Tatkow said he had received no account of Friday’s call. In her response to GMW, Boucher described the process Wilton follows but did not identify who took part that day or what follow-up, if any, Moody’s requested. As of publication, GMW has not received confirmation of any other information on details regarding the call.


