Key Points

  • Residents say the School Sisters agreed to limit development for 50 years in exchange for access to Wilton’s sewer system.
  • A land-use attorney who has lived in Wilton for 40 years challenged town counsel’s conclusion that Wilton has no standing to enforce the restrictions.
  • Selectmen plan to discuss the request for a second opinion Dec. 7. Whether they will do so in public or in executive session remains open.

Why It Matters: Whether Wilton can enforce the restrictions could shape what a future owner can build on the 38-acre property through 2063. 

A letter to the editor and lengthy public comment from a longtime resident led several other community members in asking the Board of Selectmen Monday evening to seek a second legal opinion on whether Wilton can enforce restrictions on future development of the School Sisters of Notre Dame property on Belden Hill Rd.

Thirteen years ago, when the School Sisters sought to connect to the town sewer system, they recorded a deed restriction limiting expansion on the property. Residents say the restriction was part of the agreement for sewer access. Peter Gelderman, an attorney for the Town, has said Wilton has no legal interest in the restriction and no standing to enforce it. He said the Sisters “could probably release it” before selling the property, a step that would clear one obstacle to a 280-unit retirement community proposed by Hines SL Wilton Associates LP.

Patricia Frisch, a land-use attorney who has lived in Wilton for 40 years, disagreed. She opened more than 40 minutes of public comment from almost a dozen residents at Monday’s BOS meeting by urging the selectmen to seek a second legal opinion. Several residents who spoke after her cited Frisch’s Nov. 5 letter to the board and echoed her request.

Later in the meeting, Selectman David Tatkow proposed putting the request on a future agenda. The selectmen plan to discuss it at their next scheduled meeting on Monday, Dec. 7, although they left open whether that discussion would take place in public or in executive session.

At the center of the dispute is a 2013 document titled “Declaration of Land Use Restrictions,” recorded for the 38-acre Belden Hill Rd. parcel near the corner of Wolfpit Rd. where the School Sisters formerly operated an assisted living campus for retired members of the order. The declaration restricts future uses of the property and limits expansion of the existing buildings to 10% of their gross floor area, and calls for the restrictions to be included in the deed if the property is sold. The restrictions extend to 2063.

Several speakers said they understood the 50-year restriction to be a condition of extending sewer service from Miller-Driscoll School to the School Sisters property, allowing the SSND to avoid costly septic work.

Gelderman has said the Water Pollution Control Authority (WPCA) in 2013 approved the connection without making the restriction a condition of its approval or requiring the Town to be a party to the agreement.

The question took on new significance with Hines’ continuing care retirement community proposal for the site.

Hines first presented its proposal as a nonbinding pre-application review to Wilton’s Planning and Zoning Commission (P&Z) in May 2025. The current Water Pollution Control Authority approved a sewer allocation that June, and Wilton’s Architectural Review Board praised the design at a November 2025 work session. In June 2026, the Inland Wetlands Commission approved a wetlands permit, which neighboring property owner Kari Roberts later appealed.

Hines filed its formal P&Z applications in July 2026, seeking a zoning regulation change, a special permit and site plan approval. After P&Z decided to hear the zoning change separately from the development proposal, Hines and the SSND Real Estate Trust withdrew both applications on Oct. 5, before the commission voted on either. The applicants said they intended to return to P&Z for another preliminary discussion.

“The town has no standing to enforce the restrictive covenant and the town has no legal interest in the restrictive covenant or its enforcement,” Gelderman said last year. He explained that the document names no beneficiary and said the School Sisters could probably release the restriction before conveying a title to the new owner.

Frisch disagreed.

“I respectfully ask the Board of Selectmen to obtain a second legal opinion on the enforceability of the 2013 Declaration of Land Use Restrictions,” she wrote in a Nov. 5 letter submitted as part of the record.

On Monday evening, she asked the BOS to add the matter to its agenda, again asking that the town obtain a second legal opinion.

She said that Gelderman’s analysis gave too little weight to what the declaration says about the School Sisters’ intent. She pointed to language stating that the restrictions run with the land and bind future owners for 50 years.

“The board’s decision on this issue has implications beyond the Hines’ proposed development,” Frisch said. “It raises questions of town governance, of precedent, of the reliability of the board’s willingness to enforce private restrictions bargained for at the public’s expense, and of the reliability of neighbors’ property investments made with the expectation that land-use restrictions that run with the land will be enforced by those who can enforce them.”

She also urged the board to examine correspondence between attorneys for the town and the School Sisters about how the declaration came to be.

Frisch also cited an email in which, she said, First Selectman Toni Boucher relayed Town Counsel Ira Bloom’s view that the town would have a say in any removal of the restrictions. Frisch questioned how the board could reconcile that account with Gelderman’s subsequent advice. In a Nov. 13 letter to GOOD Morning Wilton, Frisch said she takes no position on the development proposal itself.

Several speakers cited current Board of Finance member Eric Fanwick, who served on the WPCA in 2013 when it approved the sewer connection. During public comment at the Oct. 5 BOS meeting, Fanwick said the School Sisters had promised to limit development in exchange for sewer access. He argued that if the Sisters wanted to develop the property beyond those limits, they should negotiate with the town.

Resident Nicki LaMonica said Fanwick had raised a concern in 2013 about the difference between the permanent sewer connection and the 50-year restriction.

“He specifically pointed out that this would put the town at a disadvantage once those restrictions expired,” LaMonica said. “Clearly, town officials at the time were weighing the long-term impact of that sewer connection alongside the development restrictions.”

She called Gelderman’s conclusions “incredibly concerning.”

“Just because the document doesn’t explicitly name a beneficiary or state consideration, doesn’t automatically mean it isn’t enforceable,” LaMonica said. 

Belden Hill Rd. resident John Brady said the restriction had figured in his decision to buy his home, noting he researched it before buying his property in 2015, two years after the declaration was recorded. He urged the board to determine what rights the town has before deciding whether to exercise them.

Board of Finance member Kari Roberts, whose property abuts the School Sisters site, addressed the selectmen as a property owner and taxpayer; she also intervened in the Inland Wetlands Commission’s review of Hines’ proposal and later, as trustee of the Kari Skilbred Roberts Revocable Trust, appealed the commission’s approval of the wetlands permit to Connecticut Superior Court.

Roberts described the prospect of the School Sisters releasing the restrictions after receiving the sewer connection as “morally repugnant,” and she urged the BOS to seek a second opinion.

“The nuns came in their hour of need and the town did the morally correct thing,” Roberts said. “The town helped them find a financially acceptable solution to their 15-year problem.”

“The town helped SSND in their darkest hour and now SSND and their lawyers are claiming a ‘Gotcha!’ scenario. As in, ‘Too bad, Wilton. You maybe did or maybe didn’t properly document it, so therefore too bad. We reneg on our recorded land use restrictions that were obviously an agreement between us with the town and neighbors as beneficiaries,'” Roberts said.

LaMonica put it even more bluntly.

“Lying is a sin,” she said.

Boucher acknowledged the speakers.

“I just want to thank you all and assure you that this board is taking your comments — your very respectful and heartfelt comments — into serious consideration,” she said. “We appreciate you being here tonight for this.”

Later, when Tatkow proposed putting the request on a future agenda, the other members agreed they wanted to do so but were unclear on Monday whether or not that discussion would have to be held in private executive session.

“As much as I talk about transparency at this board,” Selectman Rich McCarty said, “I’m just concerned about ongoing litigation that the town’s involved in and the ongoing expense of that, so I would really err on the side of an executive session where we can talk about obtaining that second opinion.”

While McCarty did not identify a specific court case, there are two cases involving the property that are pending. In addition to Roberts’ wetlands appeal, the SSND Real Estate Trust is challenging Wilton’s valuation of the property and the town’s decision to revoke the tax exemption for two of its three parcels.

Boucher said she had questions about who should obtain a second opinion and saw value in exploring the residents’ request.

“So many of the arguments I heard were compelling, certainly, and certainly pulled at my heartstrings too,” she said. “This is a difficult situation, no question about it. I wish that there was more clarity in the original legal document that they had.”

When Selectman Matt Raimondi asked later in the meeting whether the board intended to take up the School Sisters matter on Dec. 7, Boucher replied, “It makes sense to me,” and indicated she favored an executive session. Raimondi suggested confirming with Town Counsel Ira Bloom whether the discussion qualified.

Leave a comment

IMPORTANT: ALL COMMENTS ARE MODERATED. GMW requires commenters to use FULL, real, verifiable names and emails. Comments with pseudonyms, first names only, initials, etc. will NOT be approved. If you do not provide your FULL name, GMW will NOT publish your comment. (Email addresses will not be published.) Please refer to GMW's Terms of Use for our's full commenting and community engagement policy. Comments violating these terms will not be published at the discretion of GMW editors/staff. Comment approval may take up to 24 hours (sometimes longer). If your comment has not been approved by then, refer to the policy above before emailing GMW.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.