BoS Gives 2.5% Raise to First Selectman–Even Though Vanderslice Said Not To

At Monday night’s Dec. 7 meeting of the Board of Selectmen, one of the items on the agenda was the question of the annual salary increase for the first selectman. When she introduced it for discussion, Wilton’s newly elected first selectman Lynne Vanderslice acknowledged that she didn’t necessarily have the ability to give official input, but she did want to express her thoughts.

“I would suggest that you don’t increase the salary beyond the current level,” she said.

The matter was eventually moved to executive session at the end of the meeting, and it was discussed by the other three selectmen–Michael Kaelin, Dick Dubow and Dave Clune–who invited in the town’s human resources director Sarah Taffel. Vanderslice was not in the room for the discussion.

Despite Vanderslice’s appeal, the selectmen voted unanimously to increase the salary by 2.5-percent, effective retroactively to the start of her term on Dec. 1, 2015. That raises the salary for the town’s top official from $136,108 to $139,511. According to Taffel, the salary was last increased on Dec. 1 of last year.

When asked why she recommended not increasing the salary, Vanderslice told GOOD Morning Wilton, “My recommendation was based on several factors including consistency with the goals I expressed as a candidate.”

Kaelin sent a statement by email that echoed the comments he made during the public portion of Monday’s meeting.

“My vote was based upon the position of first selectman. We are one of the few towns of our size that does not have a town manager or town administrator in addition to the first selectman, and we are the only town in our comparison group that does not provide retirement benefits to the first selectman. We are fortunate to have first selectmen who are willing and capable of doing two jobs for the price of one, and can do it without getting retirement benefits. Previous first selectmen have regularly worked 50 to 60 hours per week, and even more when necessary. Lynne will do the same. In addition to being responsible for the day to day management of the town and chairing the Board of Selectmen, the first selectman is an ex-officio member of every other town board and commission. The first selectman must attend countless meetings at nights and on weekends, and is on call 24 hours a day, 7 days per week. I do not want to limit the pool of candidates for this vital position in the future to candidates who do not need the income or retirement benefits, and I believe the first selectman should be paid more than other town employees who have lesser responsibilities within our budget constraints.”

He also noted that the increase can still be considered a budget-conscious move.

“Because of other changes in personnel costs, I know that we are able to give the first selectman a modest increase in compensation without increasing overall personnel costs, and I believe it is important we do so for all the reasons stated above.”

Dubow concurred, saying that while he very much appreciated Vanderslice’s offer to forego any salary increase for her first year in office, he voted to bump up the first selectman’s salary for several reasons.

“I did so (1) in recognition of the increasingly complex and demanding responsibilities of the job, a job Wilton expects to be accomplished without the support of a town manager or administrator that other municipalities routinely provide; (2) in order to avoid further compression in the relationship between the first selectman’s salary and compensation for other leadership positions in town government; (3) to help ensure a competitive salary that will attract an increasingly wider and economically diverse group of candidates able to seek the office in future years; and (4) because of my own personal commitment to gender equity, specifically in this case, the principle of equal pay for equal work.”

Clune says he was also thinking about the future when he agreed with the reasons for the increase provided his colleagues.

“The town benefits when we have a number of candidates willing to run for the position of first selectman. This increase helps ensure the salary is potentially attractive to a wider group of candidates in the future.”

3 COMMENTS

  1. What an incredible disappointment by the “new wave” of selectmen that supposedly ran on platforms of being more budget conscious in a time when many residents are complaining about high taxes and out of control spending. Ms. Vanderslice says she does agree with the increase (in the public forum anyway – we don’t know what was said in the private “executive session”) for a position she voluntarily ran for, and the selectmen still vote to pay her more? GIVE ME A BREAK! The First Selectman works hard? Who doesn’t? … The position has a lot of responsibility? Didn’t all of the candidates know that before they ran for the office? … Other employees in town get paid more with less responsibility? Here’s a thought: maybe those positions pay too much? … We want to make sure we get quality candidates for the job in the future? The town didn’t seem to have any problems with attracting quality candidates this past election, did it? Does anyone think the two people running this time were lacking in some way because of the salary offered? … Amazing how quickly we see politicians slip into the “spend first, cut later” way of thinking. How many times have any of us worked with someone in the private sector who was given a raise EVEN THOUGH THE PERSON SAID THEY DID NOT WANT THE HIGHER PAY? I guess this is another question that should have been asked before the election- will you vote to increase pay of your fellow selectmen within your first week in office?

  2. How did the Town of Wilton go from paying the First Selectman a decent salary of $35K-$40K (commensurate with responsibilities) with Bob Russell and Paul Hannah at the helm to over $135K under Bill Brennan? That was bad enough and now, Lynne Vanderslice is going to accept (under protest – hmmmm) $140K – what a disgrace and shame on all of the B of S members. Here’s a suggestion, since the selectmen enjoy playing Santa Claus why don’t they make up the 2.5% additional compensation from their own pockets?

Comments are closed.